Every elite athlete understands that peak performance is a direct result of rigorous training and meticulous preparation. For professional tennis player Madison Keys, who achieved a career-defining victory at the Australian Open in 2025 and is currently a formidable contender in the US Open, the process of designing and building her first home served as an unexpected, yet equally rewarding, preparatory exercise. This journey of transforming a historic Florida property into a personal sanctuary has not only showcased her evolving design sensibilities but also highlighted her commitment to personal growth beyond the tennis court.
The initial foray into homeownership for Keys and her now-husband, retired professional tennis player and current coach Bjorn Fratangelo, was a pragmatic one. Their first residence, purchased with the limited options offered by a builder, was situated in what Keys describes as "suburbia land." While functional, the home lacked the distinct character and personal flair that the tennis star, an avowed design enthusiast since childhood – recalling a vibrant bedroom decor of blue walls and a colorful curtain – began to crave. This early experience, though perhaps not fulfilling her design aspirations, laid the groundwork for a more intentional and passion-driven approach to their subsequent property search.
A Vision for Character and Charm
Keys articulated a clear desire for a home that felt less like a mere dwelling and more like a true reflection of her personality and life. "We started the search of finding something that felt a little bit more like a home instead of just a house to live in," she explained. This quest led the couple to an idyllic neighborhood in Orlando, Florida, characterized by its mature oak trees and charming historic brick roads. It was here they discovered a property with a rich past, originally a modest 800-square-foot Spanish-style casita dating back to the 1930s. However, the original structure had been significantly altered with a large, somewhat incongruous addition, presenting both a challenge and an exciting opportunity for renovation.
Keys was immediately captivated by the inherent charm of the original casita. She recognized its potential, even while acknowledging that the newer sections would require substantial renovation to harmonize with the home’s historic essence. "I looked at my husband and I was like, ‘I have to save this house. I know what it can be,’" she recalled, signaling a profound connection to the property’s potential.
The Renovation Journey: Bridging Eras and Styles
In 2022, the couple purchased the property, embarking on a comprehensive renovation project. They enlisted the expertise of Faith and Seth Freytag, the husband-and-wife team behind the local design firm Concrete to Cotton. Faith Freytag’s initial assessment of the 2,700-square-foot home was that the original casita and the addition were not visually cohesive, describing the amalgamation as a "very weird Frankenstein situation."
To address this architectural disconnect, the design team focused on integrating the disparate elements. A key strategy involved transforming the rectangular doorways in the newer addition into elegant archways, thereby echoing the classic Spanish architectural style of the original casita. The color palette and material choices were carefully selected to evoke the warmth and authenticity of the home’s exterior, particularly referencing the rich hues of the red clay roof tiles. This approach ensured a seamless transition between the older and newer sections, creating a unified and aesthetically pleasing whole.
Integrating Functionality with Personal Style
The renovation was not solely about aesthetics; it was also deeply rooted in practicality, especially for an athlete with extensive travel demands. Keys specifically requested ample closet space in the entryway to accommodate her substantial collection of tennis gear. "She’s got tons of bags and she hated just dropping them at the front entry," Faith Freytag explained. Custom cabinetry, designed by National Woodworks, was meticulously crafted to meet this need, offering both functionality and a polished finish.
A pivotal moment in the design process involved a particularly insightful tip from Keys’ social media followers. During the renovation, Keys actively shared updates with her online community, fostering an interactive design experience. One fan suggested creating paper mockups of the future kitchen cabinets, meticulously labeling them with the intended contents. This "test run" was designed to pre-emptively assess storage needs and ensure efficient organization. Keys embraced this advice wholeheartedly: "I absolutely did it. I stood in my kitchen without cabinets actually there yet, pretending." This pragmatic exercise proved invaluable, allowing her to confirm adequate storage capacity and significantly simplifying the process of unpacking and organizing once the cabinets were installed. "It made moving back in quite easy," she affirmed.
A Canvas for Creativity and Self-Expression
The renovation also served as a catalyst for Keys to explore her burgeoning creative interests. As she delved into design choices, from sourcing vintage rugs on Etsy to selecting bold fabrics, a new facet of her personality began to emerge. "I started pushing myself a little bit more and getting a little bit more creative," she stated. This creative exploration extended beyond interior design, leading her to discover a passion for painting. Her artistic endeavors now add a deeply personal touch to her home, with one of her original paintings prominently displayed in the living room, a testament to her multifaceted talents.
The Heart of the Home: Living and Dining Spaces
The living room, situated within the original 1930s Spanish-style portion of the house, features the playful yet elegant Kukka chandelier by Sarah Sherman Samuel for Lulu and Georgia. This statement piece hangs above an Arhaus sofa, complemented by Mara Hoffman for West Elm chairs and a wooden coffee table from Moe’s Home Collection. The fireplace sconces, a charming thrifted find, and a painting by Keys herself, add unique character to the space.
The dining room was envisioned as a "statement dining room moment" by Keys. This vision was realized through a custom banquette upholstered in a striking gold tiger-print fabric by Sarah Sherman Samuel for Lulu and Georgia. This luxurious seating is paired with a Joss and Main table, Athena Calderone for Crate & Barrel chairs, and a distinctive lighting fixture from Perigold, creating a sophisticated and inviting atmosphere.
The kitchen, located in the newer addition, was designed to balance modern functionality with a touch of charm. Keys opted for Designcraft cabinets in a sophisticated white and cappuccino finish. A zellige tile backsplash behind the range, framed by an archway, adds artisanal flair. The island is anchored by stylish barstools from CB2, creating a cohesive and inviting hub for the home.
A Sanctuary for an Athlete on the Move
As a professional tennis player, Keys spends a significant portion of her year traveling for tournaments. This constant movement, however, deepens her appreciation for her home. "It makes me love my house even more," she shared. The home’s design reflects this sentiment, offering a serene and personalized retreat. The primary bedroom, for instance, provides a tranquil escape, furnished with Quince bedding and a refined light fixture from Crate & Barrel. The primary bathroom features elegant Shades of Light sconces flanking a Rejuvenation mirror, adding a touch of timeless sophistication.
Beyond the Athlete: A Holistic Approach to Identity
Keys’ home renovation project has been more than just an interior design endeavor; it has been a journey of self-discovery and a deliberate effort to cultivate a well-rounded identity. She acknowledges the societal tendency to define professional athletes solely by their athletic achievements. "Professional athletes have pretty rigid schedules, and I think there’s a little bit of a societal image of [who we are]," she observed. "I’ve found that it’s really important to be more than just an athlete and find all of the things that bring you joy." Her engagement with design and painting are not merely hobbies; they are integral to building her confidence as a whole person, a confidence she believes translates positively onto the tennis court.
Sharing this personal renovation journey with her fans has also been a significant aspect of the experience. "It was fun to be able to show people some of the other interests that I have," she remarked, highlighting the value of connecting with her audience on a more personal level and showcasing her multifaceted interests beyond the realm of professional sports. This transparency and personal expression have undoubtedly resonated with her followers, offering a glimpse into the life and personality of a celebrated athlete striving for balance and fulfillment both on and off the court. The transformation of her Florida home stands as a vibrant testament to her evolving identity and her commitment to cultivating a life rich in personal passions and creative expression.
0 Comments